329: Tools That Work Better Than Consequences, with Penny Williams
with Penny Williams
Listen on Apple Podcasts | Spreaker | Spotify | iHeart Radio
What if the “problem behavior” isn’t the problem at all, but a signal? This week, we flip the script on rewards and punishments and lean into tools that actually help neurodivergent kids (and their parents) feel safer, calmer, and more connected. When a child’s nervous system is in fight/flight/freeze, the “thinking brain” goes dim. That’s why lectures, sticker charts, and lost-screen-time threats fall flat. They assume choice and control that a dysregulated brain just doesn’t have.
In this episode, I unpack three simple, connection-first strategies you can try today: co-regulation before correction, offering bounded choices to restore a sense of control, and smoothing transitions so the brain has time to shift gears. You’ll hear quick snapshots: homework battles that soften with scaffolding, morning routines that move with choice, and playground goodbyes eased by gentle time warnings. These aren’t magic fixes; they’re nervous-system aware supports that lower threat, build trust, and grow real-life skills like flexibility and problem-solving.
We also talk about why this approach is teaching responsibility, without fear. Consistency, safety, and autonomy wire the brain for emotional intelligence, which is what carries our kids into teens and adulthood with the capacity to regulate, adapt, and take ownership. Start tiny, celebrate small wins, and watch the ripple.
Ready to feel less like a referee and more like an anchor? Listen now and try one small shift this week. Then tell me how it went. I’m cheering you on.
For generations, parenting advice has emphasized consequences, punishments, and rewards as the way to shape behavior. But for neurodivergent kids (all kids actually), those strategies often do more harm than good. When a child’s nervous system is in fight, flight, or freeze, the part of the brain responsible for reasoning and learning is offline. Trying to teach in that state is like trying to explain algebra to someone whose house is on fire. Their brain isn’t available.
The problem with consequences is that they assume choice and control. They assume a child is willfully misbehaving, rather than being hijacked by a nervous system in survival mode. That’s why punishments and rewards so often fall flat, leaving families stuck in cycles of meltdowns, resistance, and frustration.
So what works better? Tools that meet kids where they are — in their nervous system — and build connection first. Three simple but powerful strategies can shift the dynamic at home.
The first is co-regulation over correction. Instead of leading with “Stop it right now,” a parent can offer calm presence and say, “I see you’re upset. Let’s take a break together.” This approach helps a child’s nervous system settle enough to re-engage their thinking brain.
The second is offering choices. Small, bounded options like, “Do you want to do homework at the table or on the couch?” restore a sense of control. When kids feel they have some say, resistance lowers.
The third is smoothing transitions. Many meltdowns are triggered by abrupt shifts. Giving a 10-minute and 5-minute warning before leaving the playground, for example, allows a child’s brain to prepare and shift gears gradually.
These strategies may seem soft, but they are anything but permissive. They work precisely because they reduce the nervous system’s sense of threat, build trust in the parent-child relationship, and model healthy coping. Over time, they strengthen problem-solving and resilience, too.
Parents often worry that without consequences, kids won’t learn responsibility. The truth is, children don’t learn lasting lessons from fear. They learn from safety. When connection comes first, kids internalize responsibility in a way that sticks. They learn how to self-regulate, how to negotiate, and how to handle difficult situations with support.
The long game is about raising kids who can manage big emotions and big responses throughout life. People with higher emotional intelligence — the ability to recognize and regulate emotions — are consistently happier and more fulfilled. And emotional intelligence isn’t built through punishments. It’s built through trust, modeling, and connection.
Replacing consequences with connection-first tools doesn’t mean lowering expectations. It means teaching in a way that your child’s brain can actually absorb. And that’s what helps them thrive.
3 Key Takeaways
Consequences and punishments assume choice, but when a child’s nervous system is in survival mode, they often have no choice to give.
Connection-first tools like co-regulation, offering choices, and preparing for transitions help reduce stress and open the door to learning.
Over time, these approaches build trust, problem-solving, and resilience, and those skills stick far longer than lessons taught through fear.
why consequences often fail for neurodivergent kids
how to use co-regulation instead of correction to calm the nervous system
how to reduce resistance by offering bounded choices
how to prepare your child for smoother transitions and fewer meltdowns
how to build long-term resilience and emotional intelligence through connection-first parenting
Resources
Some of the resources may be affiliate links, meaning I receive a commission (at no cost to you) if you use that link to make a purchase.
Subscribe to Clarity — my weekly newsletter on what’s working in business right now, delivered free, straight to your inbox.
Our Sponsor
Kids of color who have ADHD and other common learning differences often face a double stigma. But there’s a lot that families can do to address the opportunity gap in our communities. Host Julian Saavedra is a father of two. He's also an assistant principal who has spent nearly 20 years working in public schools. Join Saavedra as he talks with parents and experts and offers tips to help you advocate for your child. Listen here >>
Transcript
Penny Williams [00:00:01]: They need to be able to shift from dysregulation to regulation, to manage big emotions and big responses from their body throughout life. And that people who are able to regulate best, who have a higher emotional intelligence, are the ones who are happier and more fulfilled.
Penny Williams [00:00:25]: Welcome to Beautifully Complex, where we unpack what it really means to parent neurodivergent kids with dignity and clarity. I'm Penny Williams and I know firsthand how tough and transformative this journey can be. Let's dive in and discover how to raise regulated, resilient, beautifully complex kids together. Oh, and if you want more support, join our free [email protected] life.
Penny Williams [00:00:58]: Raise your hand if you've tried consequences, rewards or punishments and your kid still explodes, melts down, digs in harder. Yep, I've been there. You're not failing. The traditional parenting system is failing you and your kid. If you've been following along the last couple of weeks, you know we've been building a new way of looking at challenging behavior. In episode 327, we talked about the animal instincts, how your kid's nervous system shows up to keep them safe. And it shows up like an owl or a porcupine, a cheetah or a possum. Then in episode 328, we explored how to decode the signal that those behaviors are sending you the and now in this episode, we're taking the next step.
Penny Williams [00:01:51]: What do you actually do with that signal? How do you respond in a way that doesn't just shut down the behavior, but actually helps your kid to regulate and to grow and develop skills? That's where tools that work a whole lot better than punishment and consequences are going to come in. Here's the truth. When our kids are dysregulated, they cannot access the thinking brain. You cannot reason, teach, or lecture when a kid's nervous system is in fight, flight, or freeze. If their nervous system is dysregulated, their thinking brain accessibility is dim or zero. It's like trying to explain algebra to someone with when their house is on fire, their brain is not available, folks. And that's why rewards and punishments tend to fall flat. They assume choice and control.
Penny Williams [00:02:53]: I want you to hear me on that. Punishments and rewards and consequences assume choice and control. But for many kids, their nervous system has already hijacked their ability to choose. It has already cut off access to that thinking brain and they can no longer make choice. They are in full survival mode. Their nervous system has taken over and taken control. Teaching requires both safety and regulation. First, without Those consequences don't teach, they just add more stress.
Penny Williams [00:03:34]: They tend to escalate the dysregulation. So what are we going to do instead? I want to share with you three connection first tools that you can try today. Our first is co regulation over correction. Instead of saying stop it right now, try instead. Instead. I see you're upset. Let's take a break together. Your calm presence is going to help their nervous system to settle.
Penny Williams [00:04:10]: Secondly, offer choices. Give small bounded options. You could say, do you want to do homework at the table or on the sofa? It restores a sense of control because they have choice and it tends to lower resistance. And then we want to focus on smoothing transitions. Number three, many a meltdown come from sudden changes. Sudden changes without the skills to manage the emotion and potentially the executive function that is required when there's a sudden change. So try saying something like we're leaving in 10 minutes. Do you want a five minute reminder to you? That gives their brain time to shift gears.
Penny Williams [00:05:04]: It helps them to walk up to that transition while staying regulated. Let me give you a few snapshots of what these tools look like in real life. One mom I worked with had a son who always melted down around homework, as did my own kid. She kept trying consequences, no video games until your homework is done. But all it did was actually escalate things. When she then shifted to co regulation, sitting with him and saying, I could see this feels like too much. Let's take one step at a time together, he seemed to soften. They started breaking the assignments into tiny chunks.
Penny Williams [00:05:48]: And suddenly it wasn't as much of a battle every night to do homework because he was provided with the support and the scaffolding that he needed to make it doable when things are doable or regulated. Another parent told me about their daughter who resisted getting ready in the morning. Instead of demanding compliance, they shifted to offering choices. Do you want to brush your teeth before or after you get dressed? Do you want to put on your shoes before or after you eat breakfast? That really small shift gave her just enough control to move through the routine without screaming, without yelling, without escalation. And transitions. I can't tell you how many meltdowns happen simply because a kid's brain wasn't prepared to shift gears. One dad started giving his son two reminders before they left the playground. A ten minute warning and a five minute warning.
Penny Williams [00:06:58]: Hey buddy, in ten minutes we're going to be getting in the car and we're going to be leaving or we're going to be walking back to our house. Hey, buddy, in five minutes, it's going to be time to go. So instead of dragging his kid kicking and screaming to the car, his son actually began to anticipate the change to prepare his nervous system for the change. And that transition became easier and easier with that shift and over time. These aren't magic fixes, folks. There are no magic fixes, but they do reduce the power struggles because they meet kids where their nervous system really is. These strategies might feel softer, more gentle than what you're used to, but I want to share with you why they work. We're not giving up expectations of how we act and interact with people.
Penny Williams [00:07:56]: We are just shifting to what's going to work better at the moment and maybe sliding those expectations a little bit down the road into the future.
Penny Williams [00:08:11]: If you've been listening for a while, you're familiar with my Back to School.
Penny Williams [00:08:15]: Prep week, where I set neurodivergent kids.
Penny Williams [00:08:17]: And their families up for success right.
Penny Williams [00:08:20]: When the school year starts.
Penny Williams [00:08:22]: There's another podcast that will help you navigate the rest of the school year. It's called Opportunity Gap, and it's all about special education.
Penny Williams [00:08:31]: Let's be real.
Penny Williams [00:08:32]: All Those acronyms alone, IEP504FBA, BIP can be overwhelming.
Penny Williams [00:08:39]: All you want is for your kid.
Penny Williams [00:08:40]: To have the opportunity for success, right?
Penny Williams [00:08:43]: You'll hear from special educators, child psychologists.
Penny Williams [00:08:47]: And other learning experts who know their stuff and give you more realistic advocacy tools. I listened to Opportunity Gap and I was blown away. Julian Saavedra and his guests break it down in simple terms, highlight where to focus your energy, and give you simple steps to advocate efficiently.
Penny Williams [00:09:10]: So if you've ever walked out of.
Penny Williams [00:09:11]: A school meeting wondering what just happened, go search for Opportunity Gap in your podcast app. That's Opportunity Gap.
Penny Williams [00:09:30]: So here's why these particular strategies are working. They lower the nervous system's threat level. They are not giving that signal of threat. They also build trust between your child and yourself so that your child feels safe enough to learn, to listen, to process, to take action. The relationship guides everything, folks. It matters most. It is the foundation for everything in your parenting. Building trust is crucial.
Penny Williams [00:10:07]: Another reason why these work better is that they strengthen the problem solving and resilience over time. We're not just helping kids regularly, but we're also building skills. Instead of constant firefighting, you become a steady guide, a steady anchor. You're not just reacting to their behavior. There isn't this frenzy of emotion and reactivity. Instead, you're helping your child to build the skills that they're going to need for a lifetime. They need to be able to shift from dysregulation to regulation, to manage big emotions and big responses from their body throughout life. And that people who are able to regulate best, who have a higher emotional intelligence, are the ones who are happier and more fulfilled.
Penny Williams [00:11:04]: These three strategies are actually just the tip of the iceberg. But they're very powerful because they're flipping the script. Instead of punishing behavior, you're supporting regulation, you're supporting the relationship. You're supporting your kids autonomy as well. Now I know what some of you might be thinking. This sounds nice, but shouldn't kids learn responsibility? Don't they need consequences to prepare them for the real world? I can't tell you how many times I've heard this from teachers, from other parents, from family members. Sometimes this is what we're taught to focus on. Responsibility, consequences for actions, being prepared for the real world and how unfair it is.
Penny Williams [00:11:58]: But here's what I want you to consider. When we lean into connection first tools, we're not avoiding responsibility. We're not avoiding responsibility. We're teaching it in a way that sticks. Because kids don't learn well from fear. Fear based parenting is damaging. Instead, they learn from safety over time. Tools like co regulation, choices, autonomy, smoother transitions.
Penny Williams [00:12:36]: They do more than just prevent meltdowns. They build trust. They teach problem solving. They give kids a felt sense of I can handle things with support. With support. That's what builds resilience. That's what helps them to grow into teens and adults who can self regulate, who can negotiate, who can adapt and who can take responsibility. They will be available and their thinking brain will be available for all of those things.
Penny Williams [00:13:14]: Not because they're afraid of being punished, but because they've experienced what healthy coping lives looks like. You're fostering healthy coping. That's the long game. And it's worth every bit of patience and practice and time that you put into it at the beginning that you put into it now. Think of it as front loading. You're doing more now, but it's going to save you later. Before we wrap up, I want to invite you to pause and reflect for a moment. Think about one situation in your home that keeps cycling and cycling and cycling.
Penny Williams [00:13:55]: Maybe it's mornings, maybe it's mealtimes or homework. Maybe it's bedtime. That's a big one for many of our families. What usually happens there? What tools have you tried? How could you experiment with one connection first tool instead? Maybe it's pausing to co regulate before you correct. Maybe it's offering two simple choices, maybe it's giving more transition warnings. Pick just one place to practice this week. Please don't try to overhaul everything just one shift in just one scenario because even the very small shifts really ripple into big changes. Start very, very small and you will be able to collect this snowball of successes.
Penny Williams [00:14:53]: If you're ready for more, we have so many more tools, insights and scripts that you can use when we explore behavior in much more detail. At the Free Behavior SOS Summit over four days, you will hear from more than 24 experts who each bring their own tools that are going to work better than consequences. Imagine building an entire toolbox for yourself and your kid instead of trying those same tired scripts that aren't working. It's free to attend Behavior SOS Summit October 10th through 13th, but if you want to grab the All Access Pass to keep the replays to have bonus sessions and even join us for the live coaching lab that is available to you as an option. But you can completely watch all 24 sessions absolutely free, go to parentingadhd and autism.com summit and register for your free spot. Or grab your All Access Pass and join us. I really hope to see you there. The show notes for this episode [email protected] 329 I will link up the registration for the summit there and I hope to see you there.
Penny Williams [00:16:16]: And as always, on the next episode of Beautifully Complex. Take good care guys.
Penny Williams [00:16:24]: I see you. You're doing hard and meaningful work and you don't have to do it alone. If you found this episode helpful, share it with someone who needs it and leave a quick review so others can find this support too. When you're ready for next steps, the Regulated Kids Project is here with the tools, coaching and community to help you raise a more regulated, resilient child. Get more [email protected].
I help stuck and struggling parents (educators, too) make the pivots necessary to unlock success and joy for neurodivergent kids and teens, themselves, and their families. I'm honored to be part of your journey!
Host of Beautifully Complex. I help stuck and struggling parents (educators, too) make the pivots necessary to unlock success and joy for neurodivergent kids and teens, themselves, and their families. I'm honored to be part of your journey!
You don't have to do this alone! Find calm, confidence, and connection inside the FREE Beautifully Complex Parenting Hub.
Take my FREE Animal Instincts Quiz to understand your child's biological stress response and get focused on what will help you and your kid RIGHT NOW.
Transforming negative or unwanted behavior is a long and complex process. HOWEVER, there are a few actions you can take right now that will provide a big impact. These 3 high-impact strategies address foundational aspects of behavior, empowering you to help your child feel better so they can do better.
Join us for the free Behavior SOS Summit.
